top of page
Search

"I Thought I Was Clear." The Manager Mistake That's Costing Organizations

Nov 10
3 min read

Have you ever given someone an assignment, only to be disappointed with what they delivered?


They missed the deadline. Or the quality wasn't what you expected. Or maybe they did exactly what you asked, but it wasn't what you actually wanted.


And your first thought is, "I thought I was clear."


I've seen this play out countless times. Managers get frustrated because employees aren't meeting expectations. Employees get frustrated because they think they're doing what they were asked .


And sometimes, the problem isn't poor performance. It's that the expectations weren't nearly as clear as the manager thought.


We have an expectations problem.

According to Gallup's 2026 research, only 46% of U.S. employees strongly agree that they know what's expected of them at work, down from 61% in 2015.


Think about that. More than half of employees can't strongly agree that they understand what's expected of them.


Yet we expect them to perform, take initiative, and be accountable for results.

That's hard to do when the target isn't clear.


Giving someone a task isn't the same as setting expectations.

Managers are busy, and it's easy to say things like:

  • "Get that report to me by Friday."

  • "Make sure we're taking good care of that customer."

  • "I need you to take ownership of this project."


All reasonable requests. But what do they actually mean?


What should the report include? What does great customer service look like? What decisions can the employee make independently?


What's obvious to the manager isn't necessarily obvious to the employee.

When those details aren't discussed, people fill in the blanks with their own assumptions. That's where misunderstandings, rework, and frustration begin.


Four things to clarify before handing off work

I recently listened to an episode of The Modern Manager podcast in which Mamie Kanfer Stewart shared a helpful framework called the "Successfully Done Statement."


It identifies four things managers should clarify:

1. The outcome. What does the finished product or successful result look like? Focus on what needs to be accomplished, not just the activity.

2. The must-haves. What requirements or standards are nonnegotiable?

3. The deadline. When, specifically, does it need to be completed?

4. The hidden details. What are you assuming the employee already knows? This is often where things go sideways...


Here's an example:

  • Instead of saying, "Put together a summary of our customer complaints for Friday," try:

  • "I'd like a one-page summary of the customer complaints we've received this month, including the three most common issues and your recommendations for addressing them. Please send it to me Thursday by 3 p.m. so I can review it before Friday's meeting. I'm looking for an overall picture, not every individual complaint."


Same assignment. Much clearer expectations. Probably a much better result.


Clarity isn't micromanagement.

Some managers hesitate to be specific because they don't want to micromanage.

But there's a big difference between defining the result and controlling every step someone takes to get there.


Employees need to know what success looks like. They don't necessarily need to be told exactly how to achieve it.


And don't forget to make it a conversation. Ask what questions they have, whether the deadline is realistic, and what obstacles they anticipate.


It's hard to hold people accountable for expectations they didn't fully understand.


Setting clear expectations is just one of the practical skills I help managers develop through InfluenceHR's HABITS High-Retention Manager training. We focus on everyday, practical management practices that help leaders communicate, coach, build trust, and create accountability.


Because good management takes more than good intentions. It takes skills that can be learned and practiced.


If your organization is struggling with inconsistent management, missed expectations, or accountability challenges, let's talk about how to better equip your managers to lead.


Sources: Gallup, U.S. Employee Engagement, Q3 2026; Mamie Kanfer Stewart, The Modern Manager, Episode 431.

 
 

HR Consulting | Fractional HR | Winston-Salem, NC | Serving the Triad in NC and beyond

bottom of page