top of page
Search

Why Employees Underperform: 4 Causes Every Manager Should Consider

Nov 4
4 min read

You've got an employee who isn't meeting expectations. You've talked to them. Maybe more than once. You've explained what needs to improve, but nothing changes.


Now you're frustrated, and you're wondering whether it's time to part ways.


But here's a question worth asking before you get to that point:


Have you figured out what's actually causing the performance problem?


Too often, managers assume poor performance is a motivation or attitude issue. The employee doesn't care, isn't trying hard enough, or simply doesn't want to do the job.

Sometimes that's true. But not always.


And when we misdiagnose the problem, we tend to apply the wrong solution.


The 4 C's of Performance Problems

Before jumping to conclusions about an employee's performance, consider four possible causes: Clarity, Capability, Conditions, and Commitment.


Clarity: Do they know what's expected?

You might be surprised how often performance problems start here.


Managers assume employees know what success looks like because they've been told what to do. But there's a big difference between knowing your job duties and understanding what good performance looks like.


Consider:

  • Are expectations specific and measurable?

  • Does the employee understand priorities and deadlines?

  • Have you clearly communicated what needs to change?

  • Are expectations consistent, or do they change depending on who's managing?


What to do: Get specific about what successful what successful performance looks like. Don't assume that because you think you've communicated something, it has been understood.


Capability: Can they do the job?

Sometimes employees want to perform well but lack the knowledge, skills, or abilities to meet expectations.


Perhaps they were promoted into a role without adequate preparation. Maybe the job has changed, but their skills haven't kept pace. Or they simply haven't received the training and coaching they need.


Consider:

  • Does the employee have the skills and knowledge required?

  • Have they received adequate training?

  • Do they know how to perform the work, not just what needs to be accomplished?

  • Would additional coaching, practice, or support make a difference?


What to do: Identify the specific skill or knowledge gap. Then determine whether training, coaching, or additional support can realistically close it.


Conditions: Is something getting in the way?

Here's one managers sometimes overlook.


An employee can know what's expected and have the ability to do the job, yet still struggle because of the environment they're working in.


I've seen organizations expect employees to deliver results while dealing with conflicting priorities, inefficient processes, insufficient resources, or constantly changing expectations.


Consider:

  • Is the workload reasonable?

  • Does the employee have the tools and resources needed?

  • Are processes or systems creating unnecessary obstacles?

  • Are competing priorities making it difficult to succeed?


What to do: Look beyond the individual. Sometimes improving performance requires changing the conditions in which the work gets done.


Commitment: Will they do the job?

Now we get to the one many managers assume is the problem from the beginning.


Sometimes an employee understands expectations, has the necessary skills, and has reasonable working conditions—but still doesn't follow through.


This is where accountability becomes especially important.

Consider:


  • Has the employee demonstrated that they can meet expectations but consistently chooses not to?

  • Have concerns been addressed directly?

  • Does the employee understand the consequences of continued poor performance?

  • Has the manager followed through consistently?

What to do: Have a direct conversation about the performance gap, establish clear expectations and timelines, document the discussion, and follow through.

Caring about employees doesn't mean avoiding accountability. In fact, addressing concerns early and giving someone a fair opportunity to improve is one of the most caring things a manager can do.


Why Getting the Diagnosis Right Matters

Think about what happens when we apply the wrong solution.


  • We put an employee on a performance improvement plan when what they really need is training.

  • We send someone to training when the problem is a lack of clear expectations.

  • We repeatedly coach an employee when an inefficient process is preventing success.

  • Or we keep providing support and second chances when the real issue is an unwillingness to meet reasonable expectations.

The wrong solution wastes time, creates frustration, and allows performance problems to continue.

And the consequences extend beyond the individual employee.

Other team members pick up the slack. High performers become frustrated. Managers spend more time dealing with the same issues. And when problems aren't addressed consistently, accountability suffers across the organization.


Better Performance Starts with Better Questions

The next time an employee isn't meeting expectations, resist the urge to jump straight to conclusions.

Start by asking:

Is it a problem with clarity, capability, conditions, or commitment?

The answer should shape your next step.

And if you're seeing recurring performance challenges, it may be time to take a broader look at how your organization sets expectations, develops employees, provides feedback, and holds people accountable.

Because effective performance management isn't about completing annual reviews or documenting poor performance.

It's about creating an environment where people know what's expected, have what they need to succeed, receive regular feedback, and are held accountable for results.

Is Your Organization Struggling with Performance and Accountability?

At InfluenceHR Consulting, I help growing organizations build practical performance management processes that create clearer expectations, strengthen manager effectiveness, and improve accountability.

Whether your current approach needs some adjustments or a complete redesign, we can help you create a process that works for your organization and your people.


 
 
 

Comments


HR Consulting | Fractional HR | Winston-Salem, NC | Serving the Triad in NC and beyond

bottom of page